The News GodThe News GodThe News God
  • Politics
    • Trump
  • News
    • Wars & Conflicts
  • Business & Finance
  • Lifestyle & Health
  • Law
  • Sports
  • Tech & Autos
  • Home & Garden
  • Videos
  • More
    • Travel & Tour
    • Education
    • Entertainment
      • Biography
      • Net Worth
      • Famous Birthdays
    • General
    • Pets
    • Blog
    • About Us
    • Disclaimer
    • Media Partners
    • Why You Need to Read Business News Everyday
    • Authors
    • Terms of Service & Privacy Policy
Reading: South Africa: Government accused of misleading public on NHI costs
Share
Font ResizerAa
The News GodThe News God
Font ResizerAa
  • Politics
  • News
  • Business & Finance
  • Lifestyle & Health
  • Law
  • Sports
  • Tech & Autos
  • Home & Garden
  • Videos
  • More
Search
  • Politics
    • Trump
  • News
    • Wars & Conflicts
  • Business & Finance
  • Lifestyle & Health
  • Law
  • Sports
  • Tech & Autos
  • Home & Garden
  • Videos
  • More
    • Travel & Tour
    • Education
    • Entertainment
    • General
    • Pets
    • Blog
    • About Us
    • Disclaimer
    • Media Partners
    • Why You Need to Read Business News Everyday
    • Authors
    • Terms of Service & Privacy Policy
Follow US
  • About Us
  • Authors
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • My Bookmarks
  • Terms of Use & Privacy Policy
  • Media Partners
The News God > Blog > News > South Africa: Government accused of misleading public on NHI costs
NewsPolitics

South Africa: Government accused of misleading public on NHI costs

Sampson Gaddah
Last updated: November 26, 2019 9:34 am
Sampson Gaddah
November 26, 2019
Share
4 Min Read
African National Congress (ANC) NHI
SHARE

Government is misleading the public and its much-vaunted National Health Insurance (NHI) plan is unaffordable unless taxes are increased dramatically, a study headed by Prof. Jannie Rossouw, professor of economics and head of the school of economics and business sciences at the University of the Witwatersrand, has found.

Contents
NHI: Question of cost still unansweredCalls for consideration to be halted

The study, co-authored by Mike Holland of PriceMetrics, is to be handed in to the parliamentary portfolio committee on health by Solidarity trade union as part of its submission on the NHI. TheSouthAfrican has had access to a copy of the report.

NHI: Question of cost still unanswered

The report argues that the memorandum to the NHI Bill currently before the committee, as agreed to by Cabinet, “attempts to mislead the public and Members of Parliament” by avoiding any mention of the cost of providing the services of NHI, focusing instead on the initial operational costs of establishing the NHI Fund including a human resources capitation fund and some relatively minor short-term interventions.

The most recent cost estimates in the public domain were in fact released with the NHI White Paper in 2017, but that was based on 2010 values, which would have created what the report calls “a false impression of actual implementation costs.”

Related Posts

Rio Ferdinand picks his favorite to win next season's, Premier League.
Rio Ferdinand picks his favorite to win next season’s, Premier League.
Roof Collapse at Mexican Baptism Ceremony Kills 7
Fisheries Ministry sued for increasing licensing fees
What Is the Average Nursing Home Wrongful Death Settlement?

In fact, the report states that “It appears that the introduction of the NHI has not been subjected to any cost benefit analysis by the Department of Health since a 2012 analysis by Treasury.”

Rossouw and Holland calculate that the funding gap for the NHI in 2026 (when it is envisioned to be implemented) will be around R226,9 billion, which is a shortfall of more than R166 billion in current (2019) terms.

That means the funding gap by 2026 should be around 10,8% of projected government revenue, which means that taxes will have to be raised by 10,8% to make up the shortfall.

Calls for consideration to be halted

The report points out, however, that spiralling government debt has increased from 25% of the gross domestic product (GDP) ten years ago to its current levels of 60% of GDP, and that social grant spending, together with an ever increasing public service wage bill and interest on government debt now gobble up 73% of government revenue, compared to 55% ten years ago.

To add to the cramped fiscal space, state-owned entities are draining the fiscus, the turning point on the so-called Laffer Curve having been reached x- further tax increases will so stifle growth, inhibit investment and aid capital flight that it will not add to government revenue.

Rossouw and Holland furthermore calculate that the only way for the state to finance the NHI is by increasing VAT, a payroll tax on employers, a surcharge on the taxable income of individuals, higher corporate tax, higher personal income tax or a combination of these and other increases, as well as a cancellation of medical tax credits.

An effect of the proposed NHI would also be cancellation of private medical aid membership, thereby increasing the burden on the already faltering public health system,

The report therefore concludes that Parliament should not even consider the NHI Bill until it has been truthfully and accurately costed.

 

 

 

Two individuals were killed and a large number of others were injured in a shooting at an Airbnb rental in Pittsburgh.
What Happens if the Government Shuts Down?
Temple police have a suspect wanted in a knife-point robbery and a stolen bike.
A South Carolina Man arrested for threatening a judge by saying, ‘I’ll rip your face off.’
Matt Fitzpatrick wins the US Open in 2022, defeating Will Zalatoris and Scottie Scheffler’s first major victory.
Share This Article
Facebook Email Print
Share
What do you think?
Love0
Sad0
Happy0
Sleepy0
Angry0
Dead0
Wink0
Previous Article (video)Zylofon TV catches fire
Next Article Gordhan vs Moyane South Africa: Gordhan vs Moyane: Minister submits motion to grill axed Sars commissioner
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Publications

Woman married for 12 yrs files for divorce after ChatGPT claim husband was cheating
Woman married for 12 years files for divorce after ChatGPT claim husband was cheating
News
June 12, 2025
Are there any Irish jackpot slots? 
How to Maximize Your Winning With E-Wallet Slot Game
Sports
August 12, 2023
Are there any Irish jackpot slots? 
How Many Spins Should You Play On A Slot Machine?
News
October 18, 2022
Israeli attacks kill 140 in Gaza in 24 hours, medics say
Israeli attacks kill 140 in Gaza in 24 hours, medics say
News
June 18, 2025
Pennsylvania to Host 6 World Cup 2026 Matches
Pennsylvania to Host 6 World Cup 2026 Matches
Sports
June 18, 2025

Stay Connected

235.3kFollowersLike
69.1kFollowersFollow
11.6kFollowersPin
56.4kFollowersFollow
136kSubscribersSubscribe

You Might also Like

Shooting at South Carolina leaves several injured, doctor, family members dead; suspect nabbed
News

Shooting at South Carolina leaves several injured, doctor, family members dead; suspect nabbed

April 8, 2021
schiff-on-impeachment:-not-calling-witnesses-‘deprives-public-of-fair-trial’
Politics

Schiff on impeachment: Not calling witnesses ‘deprives public of fair trial’

January 26, 2020
News

An alleged sniper in Washington, DC, fired over 200 shots from the fifth floor, cops say.

April 26, 2022
Hamas spokesperson, Abdel-Latif Al-Qanoua killed
Wars & Conflicts

Isaerli Airstrike Kills Hamas spokesperson Qanoua, Hamas media say

March 27, 2025
Show More
© 2025 Thenewsgod. All Rights Reserved.
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use & Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Authors
  • Media Partners
  • Videos
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?