By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
The News God
  • Politics
  • News
  • Business & Finance
  • Lifestyle & Health
  • Law
  • Sports
  • Tech & Autos
  • Home and Garden
  • Other Categories
    • Travel
    • Education
    • Entertainment
    • General
Reading: Fox News Today: Ben Shapiro: NY Times columnist is wrong about depression and suicide rates in red states
Share
Aa
The News God
Aa
  • Politics
  • News
  • Business & Finance
  • Lifestyle & Health
  • Law
  • Sports
  • Tech & Autos
  • Home and Garden
  • Other Categories
Search
  • Politics
  • News
  • Business & Finance
  • Lifestyle & Health
  • Law
  • Sports
  • Tech & Autos
  • Home and Garden
  • Other Categories
    • Travel
    • Education
    • Entertainment
    • General
Follow US
  • Why You Need to Read Business News Everyday
  • Why You Need to Read Business News Everyday
  • Advertise
  • Advertise
The News God > Blog > Politics > Fox News Today: Ben Shapiro: NY Times columnist is wrong about depression and suicide rates in red states
Politics

Fox News Today: Ben Shapiro: NY Times columnist is wrong about depression and suicide rates in red states

Sampson Gaddah
Last updated: 2020/03/09 at 6:31 AM
Sampson Gaddah Published December 15, 2019
Share
5 Min Read
Fox News Today: Ben Shapiro: NY Times columnist is wrong about depression and suicide rates in red states
SHARE

Fox News Today:

Paul Krugman of The New York Times has posited a theory: Red states cause depression and suicide.

In a column titled “America’s Red State Death Trip,” Krugman wrote: “In 1990, today’s red and blue states had almost the same life expectancy. Since then, however, life expectancy in Clinton states has risen more or less in line with other advanced countries, compared with almost no gain in Trump country. At this point, blue-state residents can expect to live more than four years longer than their red-state counterparts.” On this basis, Krugman blasts Attorney General William Barr, who suggested this year that militant secularism lies behind rising mortality in the United States. Instead, Krugman suggested that “these evils are concentrated in states that voted for Trump, and have largely bypassed the more secular blue states.”

Krugman’s analysis is deeply flawed. It is flawed because it is far too simplistic. First off, states are not good proxies for political viewpoint within states, which would be far more telling: Texas encompasses both Austin and Lubbock, for example. Secondly, Krugman links 2016 voting patterns to 1990 data, but some of the states hit hardest by the opioid epidemic shifted over that same time frame from blue to red (e.g., Ohio, West Virginia and Michigan), demonstrating that voting may have resulted from distress, not the other way around. But more importantly, Krugman assumes that conservatism presages lower life expectancy, rather than that those in lower-income rural areas are turning toward conservatism as a result of the social liberalism pushed forward by the left.

Fox News Today: More from Opinion

This analysis, as it turns out, is false. The reality is that broad trends over time point to the fact that low-income Americans have been disproportionately affected by the rise of social liberalism: the decline in religiosity, and the concomitant collapse of church and other social institutions have undermined precisely the same people who have been hit hard by the economy. Charles Murray pointed out this phenomenon in his book “Coming Apart” nearly a decade ago: America has bifurcated between more highly educated, higher-income Americans (Murray labels them residents of Belmont) and less educated, lower-income Americans (Murray labels them residents of Fishtown).

 Lean More About Improving Skin Health

This holds true regardless of race. And contrary to popular opinion, those who are less educated and lower-income, particularly in the white community — the base of support for President Trump — have been disproportionately affected by the excesses of social liberalism. Between 1960 and 2010, the marital rate among Belmont whites ages 30 to 49 declined from 94 percent to 84 percent; the marital rate among Fishtown whites declined from 84 percent to 48 percent. Similarly, single motherhood increased from 1 percent of Belmont white college-educated women in 1970 to less than 6 percent in 2008; for Fishtown women, that number skyrocketed from 6 percent to 44 percent.

Also read: Missing Saudi servicemen linked to NAS Pensacola shooting sought; gunman made prior reported trip to NYC

Most tellingly, secularism increased for both groups but far less among Fishtown residents (from about 29 percent in 1972-1976 surveys to 40 percent in 2006-2010 surveys) than Belmont residents (from 38 percent to 59 percent). In other words, the wages of social liberalism take a deeper toll on those who require more from social institutions, both economically and culturally. Denizens of The New York Times are far less likely to have children out of wedlock than the supposed religious fanatics they oppose — but they’re also likely to push both governmental and social policy designed to promote single motherhood, for example. They don’t pay the price of the policies they push.

Good decision-making and robust social institutions have a lot to do with life success. Promotion of bad decision-making and decay of key social institutions in the name of personal freedom may seem liberating to elitists like Krugman, but there are consequences for those who don’t draw six-figure paychecks from Manhattan newspapers. Disdaining those who live in red states as victims of their own conservative backwardness isn’t merely inaccurate; it’s doubling down on stupid.

Read More

You Might Also Like

House GOP preps attack DC plan to allow illegal immigrants vote and minimize criminal penalties.

Governor Brian Kemp activates one thousand National Guard troops ahead of Georgia anti-cop riots.

South Dakota House committee denies plan to limit ballot measures.

Harris to promote abortion in Florida on Roe v. Wade’s anniversary.

Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey sworn in for 2nd full term.

Sampson Gaddah December 15, 2019
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Share
Previous Article Fox News Today: Rep. McCarthy says impeachment puts about 55 House Democrats in a vulnerable spot Fox News Today: Rep. McCarthy says impeachment puts about 55 House Democrats in a vulnerable spot
Next Article Fox News Today: Millennials are abandoning religion for good, new research shows Fox News Today: Millennials are abandoning religion for good, new research shows
Leave a comment Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Stay Connected

235.3k Followers Like
69.1k Followers Follow
11.6k Followers Pin
56.4k Followers Follow
136k Subscribers Subscribe

Ads

Latest News

Virginia man accused of inappropriately touching youngsters at Loudoun County pool.
News February 4, 2023
9 Tips for Choosing the Right Security Service
9 Tips for Choosing the Right Security Service
Tech & Autos February 4, 2023
From Batter to Bliss: The Health Benefits of Urb gummies
From Batter to Bliss: The Health Benefits of Urb gummies
Lifestyle & Health February 4, 2023
10x10 Canopy
Top 10 Reasons to Choose A 10×10 Custom Canopy for Commercial and Non-commercial Events
Business & Finance February 4, 2023

You Might also Like

Politics

House GOP preps attack DC plan to allow illegal immigrants vote and minimize criminal penalties.

February 3, 2023
Politics

Governor Brian Kemp activates one thousand National Guard troops ahead of Georgia anti-cop riots.

January 27, 2023
Politics

South Dakota House committee denies plan to limit ballot measures.

January 20, 2023
Politics

Harris to promote abortion in Florida on Roe v. Wade’s anniversary.

January 19, 2023
Show More

© 2022 Thenewsgod. All Rights Reserved.

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use & Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?